Famous Doesn't Mean Good: Elizabeth Holmes and The Myth of the TED Talk

Have you seen “You Can See Everything” yet? I have!

It’s a mind-blowing piece of art.

But it got me thinking about one of the things that put her on the map in the 2010s. Her [now-deleted] TED talk.


Everybody is talking about Elizabeth Holmes right now. So I'm going to talk about her, too.

I want to talk about one of the things that put her on the map: Her TED Talk from 2014.

Here's a telling detail: You can't find her talk on the TED website anymore. They scrubbed her. The only copy I could dig up is a blurry one with Spanish subtitles that one guy posted to his YouTube channel.

I went looking for it because that talk makes a point I've wanted to make for a long time: Just because somebody has given a TED Talk doesn't mean they're a good (or effective) speaker.

[You might argue that Holmes was effective because she received hundreds of millions in investments. You’d also be ignoring how well-connected her parents were and to whom. ‘nother story another time.]


The best communications speaker in chicago marianna swallow

Famous is not a mark of quality.

And famous is not a template.

Sometimes clients hire me and say, "Direct us like we're doing a TED Talk." Or, "We want our speeches to be more like TED Talks."

So I ask: why?

They can't really tell me. It's just this known, vaunted thing.

That's the trap. If you can't say what you admire about something, you can't emulate the part that works.

So before you say "I want this to be like a TED Talk," ask: WHY you want your presentation to be TED-like?

Then think about what you're there to accomplish:

  • Persuade your audience?

  • Inform them?

  • Connect with them?

  • Make them laugh?

Start there. Your purpose will tell you what the talk needs. A famous format won't.

Just because it's big and famous doesn't mean it's good. And it definitely doesn't mean you should build your talk to look like it.

Happy speaking!


About The Author

Hi! I’m Marianna. I take the stress out of corporate presentations and show executives how to speak with natural, easy confidence. And I have the results to prove it. I help with everything from preparation to managing anxiety and nerves to speaking with strength and confidence. In addition to Presentation Skills workshops, I offer executive coaching and Keynote speeches. To learn more, Get in touch.

Marianna Swallow

Kick-ass public speaking coach. Always fun, always compassionate, always looking to make your presentations easier. 

https://mariannaswallow.com
Next
Next

6 Places to practice your Public speaking skills